2/14 Debate

MOTION: THB Korea should allow presidential re-election.
Date: 2/14		GOVERNMENT		OPPOSITION
Introduction	Pts	Name: Youngil Jung		Name: Inseong Joe
Delivery	9 /10	Well spoken, but little monotonic	6 /10	Nervous, need more confidence
Arguments	9 /10	Effectiveness, regulation of the president,	7 /10	Lame duck, populism: irrational behavior to gain popularity
Notes	Tot 18 /20	1 POI	Tot 13 /20	1 POI: not answered completely 1 POI rejected
Rebuttal One	Pts	Name: Juwon Park	Pts	Name: Changwoo Lee
Delivery	9 /10	Clearly presented	10 /10	Strongly, clearly spoken
Arguments	8 /10	Example of US, major trend: nation-wide survey showed	9 /10	Checks and balances: too much power given to the president, populism contradicts efficiency, wording problem existed in the survey, example of 전두환: done by law, but it’s still a dictatorship
Notes	Tot 17 /20	2 POIs rejected 2 POIs taken	Tot 19 /20	10 POIs rejected 1 POI taken: well answered
Conclusion	Pts	Name: Byungwoo, Jung	Pts	Name: Seohyeon, Lee
Delivery	9 /10	well done (did not finish)	9 /10	Clearly presented, a bit fast (not finished)
Arguments	9 /10	The opposition side just criticizes everything-just critics, in politics there is only a better answer not the right answer	10 /10	Fundamental reasons: failed to do so, the opposition should criticize, clashes: good or harmful, going to work or not
Notes	Tot 18 /20	4 POIs rejected 1 POI taken	Tot 19 /20	1 POI rejected